N Engl J Med 2021 Dec 01
21-Gene Assay to Inform Chemotherapy Benefit in Node-Positive Breast Cancer.
Abstract
Background
The recurrence score based on the 21-gene breast-cancer assay has been clinically useful in predicting a chemotherapy benefit in hormone-receptor-positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)-negative, axillary lymph-node-negative breast cancer. In women with positive lymph-node disease, the role of the recurrence score with respect to predicting a benefit of adjuvant chemotherapy is unclear.
Methods
In a prospective trial, we randomly assigned women with hormone-receptor-positive, HER2-negative breast cancer, one to three positive axillary lymph nodes, and a recurrence score of 25 or lower (scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating a worse prognosis) to endocrine therapy only or to chemotherapy plus endocrine (chemoendocrine) therapy. The primary objective was to determine the effect of chemotherapy on invasive disease-free survival and whether the effect was influenced by the recurrence score. Secondary end points included distant relapse-free survival.
Results
A total of 5083 women (33.2% premenopausal and 66.8% postmenopausal) underwent randomization, and 5018 participated in the trial. At the prespecified third interim analysis, the chemotherapy benefit with respect to increasing invasive disease-free survival differed according to menopausal status (P = 0.008 for the comparison of chemotherapy benefit in premenopausal and postmenopausal participants), and separate prespecified analyses were conducted. Among postmenopausal women, invasive disease-free survival at 5 years was 91.9% in the endocrine-only group and 91.3% in the chemoendocrine group, with no chemotherapy benefit (hazard ratio for invasive disease recurrence, new primary cancer [breast cancer or another type], or death, 1.02; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.82 to 1.26; P = 0.89). Among premenopausal women, invasive disease-free survival at 5 years was 89.0% with endocrine-only therapy and 93.9% with chemoendocrine therapy (hazard ratio, 0.60; 95% CI, 0.43 to 0.83; P = 0.002), with a similar increase in distant relapse-free survival (hazard ratio, 0.58; 95% CI, 0.39 to 0.87; P = 0.009). The relative chemotherapy benefit did not increase as the recurrence score increased.
Conclusions
Among premenopausal women with one to three positive lymph nodes and a recurrence score of 25 or lower, those who received chemoendocrine therapy had longer invasive disease-free survival and distant relapse-free survival than those who received endocrine-only therapy, whereas postmenopausal women with similar characteristics did not benefit from adjuvant chemotherapy. (Funded by the National Cancer Institute and others; RxPONDER ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT01272037.).
Related Questions
What is your approach to adjuvant chemotherapy for a postmenopausal woman with pT1cN0 grade 2 ER+ breast cancer (IDC) and OncoType RS of 25?
Since the Oncotype Dx recurrence score of 25 was the upper cut-off for randomization in the TAILORx trial, and since post-menopausal women with Oncotype Dx of 25 or less did not experience any benefit from chemotherapy, I would lean towards avoiding chemotherapy in this situation. However, I would d...
How will the results of NRG GU006 and the use of the PAM50 genomic classifier impact treatment for recurrent prostate cancer?
Top line results: The prostate cancer-adapted PAM50 gene expression biomarker was validated in the NRG GU006 randomized trial to predict the differential benefit of hormone therapy, specifically apalutamide monotherapy, for patients with recurrent prostate cancer after radical prostatectomy being tr...
Given the new ASCO guidelines on SNB in early stage breast cancer, how does the omission of SNB in patients aged 50-70 impact your adjuvant radiation recommendations?
If the patient is otherwise a good candidate for APBI (age > 50, pT1 tumor, ER+, HER2 negative, Recurrence score low and intending to take endocrine therapy) that was clinically node negative and ultrasound axilla negative, I feel completely comfortable treating with APBI post lumpectomy with negati...
How do the results of INSEMA and SOUND impact the decision of omitting SLND in young women with breast cancer and offering adjuvant RT to patients who would otherwise be candidates for omission?
Both trials required radiation so I would recommend it for a young woman not getting sentinel lymph node evaluation, and would lean toward whole breast irradiation. INSEMA required whole breast irradiation and SOUND allowed partial breast irradiation (10% of patients) but the majority of patients re...
How do you approach ovarian function suppression in premenopausal women with HR+/HER2-, node negative breast cancer and intermediate OncoType dx scores (11-25) who received chemotherapy?
The SOFT/TEXT data showed that the patients who benefited from ovarian suppression + endocrine therapy were those who were <35 years old or those who had prior chemotherapy (essentially those patients who were deemed to have high risk disease). The TAILORx study demonstrated that patients with recur...
Would you avoid chemotherapy in a postmenopausal woman age >65 with T3 HR+/HER2 negative with Oncotype DX < 25?
Prior to RxPONDER, we had to speculate: https://www.themednet.org/question/8265. We have more data now. RxPONDER included T3 patients (252 or 5% were T3) (Supplementary Appendix). So my answer mirrors that of the Oncotype website: "Postmenopausal women with 1 to 3 positive nodes and Recurrence Score...
Would you send Oncotype for pre-menopausal women with HR+, HER2(-) breast cancer with a small tumor (pT1b) and micrometastatic LN involvement or recommend adjuvant chemotherapy without sending Oncotype?
That is a very good question, especially considering that the RxPONDER trial showed benefit from chemotherapy in pre-menopausal women with 1-3 lymph nodes involved by breast cancer. However, this trial excluded patients who had micro-metastatic disease as the only nodal involvement, so we can't appl...
How would you approach adjuvant systemic therapy in a HR+ premenopausal patient over the age of 50?
Since you are citing the RxPONDER study, I assume this is a premenopausal woman over age 50 with N1 node positive disease.In the RxPONDER study, for premenopausal women, the 5-year HR for iDFS with chemo was 0.6. Same for distant DFS. But the benefit was mainly seen in premenopausal women under 50. ...
How do you interpret the EBCTCG meta-analysis analyzing the magnitude of benefit of anthracyclines in early stage ER+ breast cancer?
The appreciation of studies testing the specific benefit of adding or substituting anthracyclines as adjuvant therapy for early stage breast cancer requires a historical overview (so my apologies for a very long response….). Several of the earlier trials comparing non-anthracycline therapies (primar...
Do you recommend axillary dissection for women with ER+ breast cancer and low risk Oncotype or Mammaprint if single node positive with only 1-2 SLN removed, to ensure <4 nodes positive?
No, I see no need to do dissection in this setting. Unless there is clinical or imaging evidence of gross disease, radiation should adequately control microscopic residual disease in the axilla.
Are you offering chemotherapy for premenopausal patients with HR+ node-positive breast CA with OncoType dx scores in the intermediate range of 11-25?
This is a great question. Yes, I typically recommend adjuvant chemotherapy in premenopausal women with early stage HR+ breast cancer with nodal involvement regardless of Oncotype DX RS. I do not send an Oncotype DX score in this setting due to the modest benefit of chemotherapy seen in premenopausal...
What are your top takeaways from SABCS 2022?
Here are my top 3 presentations (specifically for breast medical oncology) that I would say are most impactful (now or soon), with slides attached. GS3-04 - Capivasertib Phase III (CAPItello-291) Trial – these results will likely change standards for post CDKi progression for HR+/HER2-negative metas...
Does the magnitude of OncoType recurrence score above 26 inform decision between TC and AC/T in ER+ HER2- 1-3 node positive, postmenopausal patients with breast cancer?
We don't have any evidence for correlating recurrence score with choice of chemotherapy. Based on RxPONDER, we know that patients with 1-3 positive lymph nodes and scores less than 25, do not benefit from chemotherapy. Based on retrospective data, we have enough evidence that scores more than 30 wou...
Would you offer OFS/AI alone or with the addition of chemotherapy in a premenopausal female with ER+/PR+ breast cancer with microscopic LN involvement and an OncoTypeDx score <11?
Oncotype recurrence score (RS) testing provides both prognostic and predictive information. This is a tumor with a low score and has an excellent prognosis, regardless of what treatment is given. Chemotherapy would not be necessary in an endocrine-sensitive tumor such as this.The issue, of course, c...
Would you offer adjuvant chemotherapy to a post menopausal woman with T1-T3 primary tumor with 4 positive axillary LNs and OncotypeDX score less than 15?
The recurrence score and other genomic assays have been clinically useful in predicting chemotherapy benefit in HR+, HER2-, lymph-node–negative breast cancer and more recently in women with 1-3 positive lymph-nodes (Kalinsky et al., PMID 34914339). At this time, there is no role for genomic assays w...
How would you approach treatment for a pre-menopausal patient with PR-positive, ER-negative, HER2-negative cT1c N1 breast cancer?
The prevalence of ER- PR+ HER2- breast cancer is relatively low and probably ranges from about 0-8%, with concerns about technical errors in HR status determination by IHC often being expressed in this instance. Because of this, I would consider repeat receptor testing at some point (an additional b...
Would you give chemotherapy to a post menopausal woman with ER/PR positive HER2 negative breast cancer, T2N1 with 3+ lymph nodes, Ki-67 30% and OncoType RS of 10?
I would not give this postmenopausal woman adjuvant with a recurrence score of 10 based on RxPONDER trial. In that trial women with recurrence scores of 25 or less were randomized to receive chemotherapy + endocrine versus endocrine therapy alone. The Kaplan Meier curves were superimposable. I would...
Would you offer adjuvant chemotherapy to a woman in her 40's s/p TAHBSO with T2N1 ER+/PR+ breast cancer with oncotype score 21-25?
Based on RxPONDER trial, post-menopausal women with operable, hormone receptor positive, HER2 negative breast cancer with metastatic disease to 1-3 axillary nodes derived no benefit from chemotherapy if Oncotype dx recurrence score was 25 or less. Analysis by age did not affect this. I would, theref...
Would you utilize OncotypeDX to guide decision making for a male with ER+ HER2- breast cancer and 1-3 positive sentinel lymph nodes?
I would be wary of using Oncotype Dx to guide treatment decisions for males with 1-3 positive lymph nodes. If we learnt anything from the prospective RxPONDER data, it’s that the biology of tumors varies in different cohorts of HR+/HER2- breast cancer patients. The Recurrence Score (RS) algorithm wa...