Would you ever offer definitive XRT in a patient with an elevated PSA (assume over 30) but who refuses prostate biopsy?
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Academic Institution
Absolutely not! There are too many benign processes that can cause an elevated PSA. Furthermore, patient-specific treatment options would differ based upon pathology. Gleason scoring is a primary driver for categorizing AJCC and other risk classification schemes. Genomic classification also requires...
Comments
Radiation Oncologist at Delaware Valley Urology Cancer Treatment Center If the patient has a rock hard, nodular prostate g...
Radiation Oncologist at Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Plymouth Jeff is correct. Even in a patient without a large...
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Academic Institution
I agree with @Jeff M. Michalski. I would not offer definitive treatment without a definitive diagnosis. The key here is probably to understand why the patient is refusing biopsy and how that plays into his goals of care.
Comments
Radiation Oncologist at Washington University School of Medicine A biopsy does more than establish a cancer diagnos...
Radiation Oncologist at UC San Diego I definitely agree.
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Community Practice
I had a patient who did not have a blood dyscrasia, although bled profusely on 2 occasions and required hospitalizations for hypovolemic shock. He refused further biopsies. If a DRE is c/w CAP and a mpMRI suggests PI-RADS 4-5, 4K suggestive, then I would treat him definitely and put aside all of the...
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Community Practice
I recall two patients with "clinically obvious" prostate cancer, including PIRADS-5 MRI finding, treated without biopsy.
Both had one thing in common - severe thromboembolic disease, with prior history of life-threatening complications with even brief withdrawal of their anticoagulation regimen (pu...
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Academic Institution
I agree completely with @Jeff M. Michalski. I am sorry for posting anecdotal stories, but I have had a number of men with markedly elevated PSA levels, some over 100 all due to having it drawn after a long bike ride (road bikes) who ended up with negative biopsies and normalization of PSA with avoid...
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Community Practice
The illustrious @Michael J. Dattoli and @Donald B. Fuller describe a few situations where XRT without pathological confirmation could be considered. However, aren't these the sort of patients who are at higher risk for post-treatment bleeding, rectal ulcers, and an indication for biopsies that can l...
Answer from: Radiation Oncologist at Community Practice
It is not going to be long before we will all be presented with this decision about forgoing a biopsy. The shove a needle in its kind. Suh et l., PMID 29230413
Comments
Radiation Oncologist at Washington University School of Medicine Precisely why I mentioned future liquid biopsies!
If the patient has a rock hard, nodular prostate g...
Jeff is correct. Even in a patient without a large...