If an average-risk, physically fit, resected stage II colon cancer patient has a positive signatera result (3.2 MTM/ml), would you recommend adjuvant chemotherapy?
Answer from: Medical Oncologist at Community Practice
A Positive Tumor-informed assay like signatera is not just a prognostic or predictive marker, but more so signifies PERSISTENCE of disease. A stage-2 average risk is not average risk anymore once you have a positive ctDNA result. Maybe in the future, the TNM would be revised to say TNM-MRD (Sta...
Comments
Medical Oncologist at Texas Oncology Dallas Dr. @Kasi, if a stage 2 or 3 colon cancer patient ...
Answer from: Medical Oncologist at Academic Institution
I respectfully disagree on this issue with my colleague, Dr. @Kasi. I do not draw, nor recommend, ctDNA in stage II or III colon cancer patients outside of a clinical trial. I would not give a favorable risk stage II patient chemo based on such a test. Dr. Kasi has cited the study by Dr. Tie et al.,...
Comments
Medical Oncologist at City of Hope Orange County Hi Dr.@Leonard Saltz,
Always open to suggestions ...
Medical Oncologist at Kaiser Permanente Dr. @Pashtoon M. Kasi: I've thought this as well b...
Medical Oncologist at Hematology Oncology Consultants This is taken from page 8 of NRG-GI008 protocol:
...
I strongly would recommend adjuvant chemotherapy in the stage II colon patient with positive postoperative ctDNA. In my discussion with other GI oncologists, most agree with this position. I feel that there is sufficient data to support this plan. The main dilemma is the situation where ctDNA is pos...
Answer from: Medical Oncologist at Community Practice
I thoroughly support the use of ctDNA in adjuvant tx decisions for Stage II colon cancer.Stage II colon cancer identification as “favorable” or “ unfavorable” based on path and clinical risk factors may increase expected relapse risk from standard 15% up to perhaps 30%. This ...
Answer from: Medical Oncologist at Community Practice
Post-surgical ctDNA has been studied as a marker for increased risk of recurrence in stage I-III colon cancer in several studies. In one prospective, multicenter study of 130 patients with stage I-III colon cancer, ctDNA detected 30 days after surgery was seven times more likely to be associated wit...
Dr. @Kasi, if a stage 2 or 3 colon cancer patient ...