From my review of literature, the rate of contralateral neck failures with ipsilateral radiotherapy for lateralized tonsil T1-2 N2a disease is very low, as below. However, only a minority of studies comment on ECE status or the size of N2a nodes in the range 3 to <6 cm (bigger potentially more obstructive leading to greater risk of backflow).
- Maskell et al 2019: 0/5
- Chin et al 2017: 0/10 (among all ipsilateral patients: LN >3 cm 46%, ECE 77%)
- Kim et al 2017: 0/6 (among all ipsilateral patients: ECE 26%)
- O'Sullivan et al 2016: 0/11
- Kennedy et al 2016: 0/8
- Rackley et al 2016: 0/12 (among all ipsilateral patients: LN >3 cm 45%, ECE 27%)
- Ye et al 2015: 1/7
- Dan et al 2015: 0/14 (among neck dissection patients: ECE 52%)
- Lynch et al 2014: 0/31 (among all ipsilateral patients ECE 20%)
- Liu et al 2014: 0/14
- Koo et al 2013: 0/2
- Al-Mamgani et al 2013: 0/18 (among all patients: 18% ECE)
- Chronowski et al 2011: 0/21
- Rusthoven et al 2009: 0/3
Cumulative contralateral recurrence risk from above studies = 1/162
I have the same question mostly related to ECE sta...